Catching Silver Creek’s Brown Drake Hatch

Silver Creek, Idaho June 2013

Silver Creek, Idaho June 2013

The country is covered with famous fly fishing hatches, especially here in “God’s  Country” (or at least “God’s Fly Fishing Country”), the rugged and beloved Northwest.      

Massive aquatic insect hatches are scattered across the region, from the green drakes and salmonflies on the legendary Henry’s Fork of the Snake to the stoneflies of Oregon’s Deschutes Riveror the monstrous salmonflies that alight each June across the waters of Southwest Montana.

Folks of all ages flock to check out the annual brown drake hatch on Silver Creek.

Folks of all ages flock to check out the annual brown drake hatch on Silver Creek.

And while these all draw anglers from far and wide, it’s tough to argue that any hatch is as unique and special as the brown drake on Silver Creek (check out SIlver Creek Outfitter's short, very cool video about the brown drake hatch).

Each spring (this year it ran roughly through the first week of June), anglers and even non-anglers flock to Silver Creek like moths to a flame. The parking lots and campgrounds at Silver Creek West and Point of Rocks are packed as full as old tackle boxes.

Despite the crowds and the crowded banks in places usually only lightly sprinkled with people, the charged atmosphere is relaxed and friendly. When another spectacular dusk descends and evening begins in this magical spot of Idaho’s high desert, the air around the Creek is filled with large Mayflies in swarms as thick as fog. It’s also filled with the energy of people—whether they fish or just watch—in awe and inspired by the power of nature.

A feisty brown trout that couldn't resist one last brown drake before the hatch ended for another year.

A feisty brown trout that couldn't resist one last brown drake before the hatch ended for another year.

The brown drake hatch on Silver Creek not only draws lots of anglers, it also allows the carloads of non-fishers who swing by to check out the hatch to get a glimpse of the magic appeal of trout (and the cool stuff they eat and spectacular places they call home). Allowing those who don’t fly fish to get a peak at what appeals to those of us who are addicted to it—or at least, we hope, it helps us seem a little less crazy to them.

I was lucky to catch the brown drake hatch a couple times towards its tail end this year. Once as a spectator, rooting on anglers with my two young sons and a couple of non-fly fishing adults—who each used the adjective “amazing” to describe the event. The second evening I was lucky enough to catch the end of the hatch with a rod in one hand and a beer in the other (luck does seem to favor the well prepared).

Sun sets upon another gorgeous spring day on Silver Creek.

Sun sets upon another gorgeous spring day on Silver Creek.

Luck was indeed with us both evenings. On the first, which was the last big night of this year’s brown drake hatch, the fisherman the boys chose to root for was the only person we saw actually hook and land a nice one. The angler was even friendly enough to thank my two-year-old son, Sam-I-Am, for letting everyone else know about his success after Sammy pointed and yelled out “He caught one!” when the guy walked past us a little while later.

On the second night, which turned out to basically be the end of the hatch, I was fortunate enough to hook into one. Since the fishing was pretty slow that evening, when the healthy brown trout splashed out of the water trying to throw the hook, the other anglers around me, and even the few folks watching from the bank, cheered and offered up some “Attaboys!” It was a somewhat surreal experience. It was the first time I’ve had anyone but my boys or my buddies hoot and holler when I was the one who hooked a fish. Sometimes it’s better to be lucky than good. 

It also helps to be surrounded by people pulling for you, swept up in the glory of Mother Nature doing some of her most impressive work in one of the most spectacular setting the Gem State (or fly fishing world) has to offer.

The brown drake hatch on Silver Creek is something special indeed. It feels a lot more like a festival than it does a fly fishing phenomenon.

Anglers line the water as the day ends and the brown drake hatch begins at Point of Rocks.

Anglers line the water as the day ends and the brown drake hatch begins at Point of Rocks.

Casting Like Clark Gable

Clark Gable and fourth wife.

One of the biggest reasons anglers have such affection for the Eastern Sierra is because the region has essentially been forgotten by time.

Little has changed over the last century on the Eastside. The towns are still made up of the same old buildings, the Sierra Nevada is still as wild and stunning as ever, and the rivers still run their same meandering routes (only now-a-days the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power isn’t allowed to run them dry).

Some even say it seems like the sleepy town of Bridgeport has been frozen in time. Although just plane frozen is often a better description, as Bridgeport suffers from inversion layers and regularly records the lowest daily temperature in the lower 48 states.

One of—if not the—oldest buildings in Bridgeport is Ken’s Sporting Goods on Main Street. Ken’s is a fire engine red, two storied log cabin that’s been in business since 1931 and is one of the only tackle shops on the Eastside that stays open year round. 

“Nobody knows exactly how long the building’s been here. It’s older than the courthouse (since 1890) next door because they actually used to have the courtroom upstairs,” said Rick Gieser, who’s run Ken’s and has been in Bridgeport for over three decades. “This place also used to be a bar and a soda fountain, but it’s best known because Clark Gabel used to hang out here.”

Besides being a famous actor, Clark Gable was also known as an avid outdoorsman. If Mr. Gable was still alive and could hit up one of his old, favorite haunts for fishing advice, Rick knows exactly what he’d tell him.

A fine East Walker rainbow.

“The East Walker River on the Nevada side is where to go now. The 15-mile stretch known as the Rosaschi is great. The average catch is about 9lbs, 12 to 18 inches,” Rick said, adding that at this time of year only single barbless hooks and artificial lures are allowed. Plus, you’ll need a Nevada fishing license, which Ken’s sells for $18 for the first day, with another $7 for each additional day.

From “The Elbow” down, however, Nevada rules apply and up to 5 trout may be kept. Besides rainbows, the East Walker is well known for browns, a few cutthroats and a healthy population of Montana White Fish.

As for lures, Rick recommends small Rapalas and Panther Martins this time of year. Anglers have been having luck recently, he said, with Mayfly nymphs, small caddis nymphs, midges and blue winged olive dry flies.

“Every once and a while somebody will get lucky and gets a freight train,” Rick said with a smile.

Even though it’s been a long time since any trains have run through the Eastern Sierra or Clark Gable has cast a line in any of the region’s waters, the place itself—much to most angler’s delight—hasn’t changed much.

-Mike McKenna